Rice University logo
 
Top blue bar image The American Civil War Era
The primary course blog for HIST 246, Spring 2011
 

Archive for the ‘Assignments’ Category

Some final announcements

Friday, April 22nd, 2011

First, please be sure to extend your thanks to Mercy, either in comments to this post or by email, for all the work she has done for our course this semester! In addition to grading your blog posts, writing some outstanding round-ups about your posts, and lecturing to our class about her research, Mercy has been doing lots of work behind the scenes on our Dowling archive. Thanks, Mercy!

Second, as noted on the syllabus, you have the opportunity to write a third position paper to replace one of your earlier position paper grades. To take advantage of this opportunity, you must download the prompt and packet of readings from OWL-Space and submit your paper by 11:59 p.m. on May 4. When submitting your paper, you also must specify which earlier position paper you would like to replace. This paper is totally optional, so please think carefully about whether you have the time to take it on, and let me know if you have questions.

Blog Post #9

Monday, March 28th, 2011

Your ninth blog post will basically be a “progress report” on the work that you do this week in conjunction with your small group project. Tomorrow in class, I will be allotting time for you to talk with your group members and develop a list of “next actions” that you need to take to get your project off the ground. Your group will assign each member one or more of these next actions. Your assignment for Blog Post #9 will then consist of two parts:

  • Write a post discussing what you have done to complete the “next action(s)” assigned to you by your group.
  • Then, you must write a comment on the posts for each of your other group members. These comments can offer suggestions, questions, or discussion what the next step to take should be. The comment can either be in response to the original post, or in response to other comments left on the post.

Because your library assignments are due Wednesday night, I am slightly revising the deadlines for this blog post assignment. Your blog post should be published by Friday, April 1, at 5 p.m. You should have your comments on the other posts on your group blog posted by Monday, April 4 at 9 a.m..

These are the firm deadlines for this assignment, but be aware that time is of the essence on these group projects. To finish these projects by the deadline, your group needs to get moving fast, especially since next week you will meet with me to draw up a contract for the project. The sooner you can get your posts published, and the sooner you can offer your comments to other group members, the quicker you can move on to the next actions you need to take.

Library Assignment #2

Monday, March 21st, 2011

Fondren Library

Your next library assignment will allow you to investigate how the story of Dick Dowling and the Battle of Sabine Pass have been remembered and retold in books and schoolbooks over the last one hundred and fifty years. Each of you will select

To complete the assignment, you will need to follow these steps. All of the steps must be completed by 11:59 p.m. on Wednesday, March 30.

STEP 1: Go to this Writeboard, enter the password distributed in class (it’s the same password we used for Library Assignment #1), and then select one of the books on the list. Just as you did last time, edit the Writeboard and put your last name next the title that you are claiming.

STEP 2: Locate the book and any other editions of the book published in other years in Fondren library. You may wish to talk to a librarian to make sure that you can find and access the book(s) you need.

STEP 3: Examine the book and make some notes to yourself about what kind of book it is. Is the book a textbook meant for use in schools? A popular history text? Was it published in Texas or outside of Texas? When was it published first, and what was going on in the country either then or at the time of later editions? Who is the author and what can you find out about him or her, either from the book itself or from other sources like the Handbook of Texas? Were there multiple authors, editors, and compilers involved in making the book?

STEP 4: Look inside the book and locate any passages that talk about Dick Dowling and the Battle of Sabine Pass. If these topics come up in the book, carefully transcribe the complete passage into a document on your computer. If there are multiple editions of the book, check to see if the section that talks about Dowling remains the same in later editions; if it changes, transcribe the new passages as well, making careful note of which edition(s) the passages come from. (Note: If Dowling and Sabine Pass don’t come up in the book, make note of that and see if you can come up with reasons why it doesn’t. Is the Civil War in Texas discussed at all? If so, how?)

STEP 5: Write a blog post about what you’ve found. The post should conform to these specifications:

  • The title of the post should be the author of the book you examined.
  • At the beginning of the post, provide a full bibliographic citation of the first edition of the book you studied, using the formatting guidelines provided by the Chicago Manual of Style.
  • In a paragraph, briefly summarize, using mainly your own words, the author’s presentation of Dowling and the battle or, if the author doesn’t talk about the battle, what parts of the Civil War era in Texas the author talks about instead.
  • In a paragraph, briefly summarize any changes in the author’s presentation in later editions, including changes in fact or wording that you noticed. (This won’t apply if there weren’t multiple editions.)
  • In a paragraph, briefly report on the reflections you made as part of STEP 3, and any information you located about the kind of book you had.
  • Finally, at the end of the post, include your full transcriptions of the passages that you located having to do with Dowling and Sabine Pass. Make sure you indicate what pages the copied passages come from, and use the “blockquote” function within WordPress to make the transcribed passages stand out clearly as quotes from the book.
  • Before “publishing” to WordPress, make sure that the box next to “Library Assignments” (in the “Categories” panel on the right hand side of the dashboard) is checked.

Any questions about these steps? Leave them in the comments here or email Dr. McDaniel for more information. Remember that all of these steps must be completed by midnight on Wednesday, March 30. The blog post that you will write for this library assignment is not a substitute for Blog Post #9, which will be a separate assignment having to do with the group projects.

Blog Post #8

Friday, March 18th, 2011

On Tuesday, we will be discussing Bruce Levine’s Confederate Emancipation in class. For Blog Post #8, which is due at 9 a.m. that morning (instead of on the usual Thursday deadline), I would like you to write a post addressing ONE of the following prompts, based on your reading of the Levine book:

  1. How does Levine explain why, when, and how Confederate officials began to embrace the idea of enlisting slaves as soldiers? Based on what you’ve learned about making causal arguments in your position papers and in our in-class discussions, do you find his explanation persuasive?
  2. The title of the book is “Confederate emancipation.” Is “emancipation” the best word for what Confederate supporters of slave enlistment were envisioning? How did their notions of “emancipation” compare to the ideas we’ve seen in the “Emancipation Proclamation” and other federal policies like the Confiscation Acts?

Optionally, after addressing your prompt, you may also use your post to discuss anything that you found surprising, confusing, or particularly interesting about the book.

Blog Post #6

Friday, February 18th, 2011

Your sixth blog post assignment is based on Library Assignment #1. Write a blog post summarizing AND analyzing the two articles that you located in the library.

As you discuss the article from List A, please include any pertinent things you noticed about the context surrounding the article. For example, what else was going on in Houston or the state and country that day that might shed light on the way Dowling was remembered at that moment? Does the placement of the article in the paper (front page, or opinion pages, or lifestyle pages, etc.) change the way you see the article?

Since the article from List B will be new to members if the class, you may also want to revisit some of the earlier research questions that we’ve raised about Dowling and apply them to this article. Does this article help answer some of our earlier questions? Does it raise new questions?

Your blog post is due Thursday, February 24, at 9 a.m.

Library Assignment #1

Tuesday, February 15th, 2011

Map of the Microfilm Room in Fondren

Your first library assignment will require you to locate, digitize, and transcribe newspaper or magazine articles about Dick Dowling, the battle of Sabine Pass, and/or the ways they have been remembered and represented over time. The digital items you create as part of this library assignment will eventually be included in the Omeka-based online archive of Dowling materials, so it is especially important to follow the instructions in this prompt carefully. The quality of this archive depends on you.

Here is a step-by-step guide to completing Library Assignment #1.

STEP 1: Go to this Writeboard link and enter the password distributed in class. Now, select one newspaper/magazine issue from List A AND one issue from List B. To claim your issues, click the “Edit This Page” button, and then put your last name in parentheses after the date of your issue. Then, be sure to enter your name in the box at the bottom of the page and click “Save as the Newest Version.” Failing to click this button will erase whatever changes you make and may enable another student to come along later and claim an issue you thought was yours.

STEP 2: Next, go to Fondren library and figure out how to view the two issues you have selected. Most of the Chronicle and Post articles will be available on microfilm in the basement. The Confederate Veteran is available in bound volumes in the Fondren stacks. The other titles should also be available in Fondren; use the catalog to find out where. If you have trouble locating your issues, talk to a reference librarian or email Mercy.

STEP 3: Look through the entire issue you’ve been assigned, and locate any article or item relating to Dowling, Sabine Pass, or the Dowling statue. As you look for articles about Dowling, you should also take some notes about the other kinds of articles and news in this issue of the paper. What else is going on in this issue or around this time? You may wish to look at a couple of issues before and after your assigned issues to get a sense of the context, and you may discover articles that are not specifically about Dowling that you still think are relevant to the sorts of research questions you’ve been asking in your blog posts (about, for example, perceptions of the Confederacy, of slavery and race, or of Irish Americans and Catholics). Save your notes as they may come in handy for Blog Post #6.

STEP 4: Create digital reproductions of the articles you find related to Dowling and Sabine Pass. You should scan the articles as *.TIFF files, using a resolution of 400 DPI. If there is a photograph, use “grayscale.” If there is only text in the article, then “black and white” will suffice. (For help scanning the articles, you can consult librarians in Fondren; they are there to help you!) All of the issues on List A and List B have at least one article about Dowling in them, so you should have at least two *.TIFF files by the end of this step, but you may find other articles you want to digitize because they seem related, and your article may have multiple pages, requiring multiple TIFF files. Give each of your files a brief, unique filename. Check to make sure the file is legible when you open it, and that you can read the words. If zooming in is necessary to read the article, make sure there is not too much pixelation when you zoom in to read. MAKE SURE YOU NOTE THE SECTION AND PAGE NUMBER ON WHICH THE ARTICLE APPEARS.

STEP 5: Transcribe the articles using a word processor. Type out each article word for word in its own document, being careful to avoid typos and indicating in brackets any word you’re unsure of. Save each document using the same filename you used for the image file, but be sure the extension for the file name is different from the image file (e.g., *.doc instead of *.tif).

STEP 6: Finally, log in to OWL-Space and navigate to the tab for HIST 246. You should see a folder called “Dowling Digital Archive Files.” Next to that folder, click on “Add,” and then select “Upload Files.” Now upload both the TIFF image files and the transcription documents you’ve created to the OWL-Space folder.

STEP 7: Now go to this Google form, and for each item you have scanned and transcribed, fill out the information on the form. You will need to fill out the form and press “submit” for each article you have scanned. These fields will provide the metadata for your item, so it is extremely important to fill out the fields as completely and accurately as possible. BE SURE TO PRESS SUBMIT SO YOUR DATA IS NOT LOST. To protect your data, you may want to fill out the answers to the form in a file on your hard drive and then copy and paste them into the form.

All of these steps must be completed by MIDNIGHT on Wednesday, February 23. It is especially important to meet this deadline because your Blog Post #6 will also relate to this assignment, so don’t wait until the last minute. Completing this assignment will require advance planning; technological glitches, library hours, and eleventh-hour problems are not extenuating circumstances that would excuse a failure to meet the deadline. Start soon and you’ll finish happy.

You will receive a grade for this assignment based on your precision and thoroughness in following these instructions, as well as on the thoughtfulness and concision of the brief description you provide about the item when filling out the Google Form. The grade is worth 10% of your total grade.

Blog Post #5

Friday, February 4th, 2011

Program for the Dick Dowling Monument Rededication, Houston Public Library (HMRC SC1268-01-01)

In your second blog posts, you closely examined the Dick Dowling statue in Hermann Park and came up with some excellent research questions about the statue itself and the memory of the Battle of Sabine Pass. In this blog post, you’ll have the opportunity to do research with primary source documents to answer some of those questions and to generate more.

STEP 1: Read and Research. Before writing your post, go back and look at some of the questions that you and your classmates wanted answered about the Dowling statue. Then, spend at least an hour or two browsing through the Houston Public Library Digital Archives related to Dowling and the Statue. (The image in this post is an example of the kind of thing you’ll find in the archive: an invitation to the dedication ceremony held at the statue in 1997.) See if you can find anything that you think helps answer a question you or another student has about the statue. As explained in class on Tuesday, make note of the specific call number (usually something SC-1268-01-01) for any item of interest to you; the call numbers are listed in the navigation pane on the left. Note that to navigate the archive you should use a web browser that can easily load PDF files within the browser itself, like Safari or Explorer. Optional: As you try to answer your questions, you may also wish to consult the article “Dick Dowling and the Battle of Sabine Pass” by Andrew Forest Muir, a former professor here at Rice (available here as a PDF), or the book Sabine Pass, by Edward Cotham, which is available on desk reserve at Fondren.

STEP 2: Report. As you write your post, begin by reporting on what you found in the archive. What questions about Dowling can the item(s) help answer? In your report, you may cite the Muir article and/or the Cotham book if you would like, but be sure to include at least some citation to the items in the archive itself, using the call numbers you recorded while browsing.

STEP 3: Raise New Questions. Conclude your post by generating some new question(s) about the statue or about the memory of Dowling that was prompted by your browsing through the archive.

This post will be due by 9 a.m. on Thursday, February 10. You may also notice comments on your posts being left by some Rice students whose names you won’t recognize. This semester, four students are enrolled in an independent study course (HIST 300) that is focused on public history and Civil War Memory. They will be working intensively on the Omeka archive that we will also be working in our class, and they have already read and discussed Cotham’s book on Sabine Pass. Two of these HIST 300 students, Kat and Jocelyn, are in our class; two of them, Ryan and Jaclyn, are not. I’ve encouraged all four of them to chime in on your posts when and where they can shed light from their deeper study of the battle and of Civil War memory.

Blog Post #4

Friday, January 28th, 2011

This week’s blog post requires that you read the following two articles:

Notice that for the Thomas and Ayers article, you’ll have to navigate through the site, starting with the “Introduction” and then clicking through the other sections indicated on the left-hand sidebar. The links along the top of the page (“Evidence,” “Historiography,” and “Tools”) give you a wealth of historical documents and data that you may also wish to browse at your leisure. The evidence in these sections is also “linked” in the article text, so that as you are reading the article, you can jump directly to articles, maps, and primary sources cited by the authors. If all of this seems confusing, you can click on the “Tools” link and then click on “Reading Record”–this page will show you which sections of the article you have read, and which ones you still need to read. The most important thing for this assignment is to get through all of the “Analysis” pages, but I think you’ll find many of the “Historiography” and “Evidence” pages interesting and useful, too.

Whig Campaign Badge for Presidential Election of 1844

In class this week, we have been emphasizing sharp contrasts between the North and the South. Many historians–we’ve been calling them “fundamentalists”–point to these sharp contrasts, created largely by the slow disappearance of slavery in the North and its growth and expansion in the South, to explain the coming of the Civil War. Both of the articles linked above take a slightly different position on the coming of the Civil War, however, one which more closely resembles a “neo-revisionist” point of view. (Kornblith calls it a “modern revisionist” point of view.)

For this assignment, select one of the two articles and write a post that (a) summarizes the author’s argument by identifying the main conclusions and the major reasons given in support of them, and (b) explains why you are or are not persuaded by the article’s argument. If you disagree with the author, give specific evidence (from other readings or lectures in class) that you think undermines the author. Even if you agree with the author, you need to explain why alternative points of view–like the “fundamentalist” position–are less persuasive.

Your blog post should be published on your small group blog and is due by 9 a.m. on Thursday, February 3.

Blog Post #3

Friday, January 21st, 2011

As you work on your third blog post this week, you may want to refresh your memory about the rubric Mercy is using when evaluating your posts.

One of the key components of the assignment is to make sure that you respond directly and fully to the assignment prompt. It is perfectly fine for you to offer your own thoughts, unrelated to the prompt, in your post, but make sure that before doing that you have clearly and completely addressed the prompt at hand.

Also, take some time to read what other students have already posted as you craft your response. There are three reasons why this is a good idea. First, your fellow classmates are sharp; they have ideas worth reading! Second, one object of this assignment is to show that you’ve done and comprehended the reading; if you only repeat what another student has already said, it makes it hard to evaluate how well you yourself understood the reading. This doesn’t mean you can’t agree with a point that has already been made, but you can still demonstrate that the point is yours by providing new evidence in support of it, or using different parts of the reading to bolster the point. Finally, the best posts–the ones most likely to get A+ marks–are the ones that show originality of insight. Reading what others have said can both spark new, original insights and also help you identify which of the thoughts you’ve been having are unique insights that have not yet been shared.

Camp Scene, 22nd New York Volunteers

Photograph from Matthew Brady Collection of the National Archives

This week’s blog post assignment relates to the required book by Chandra Manning: What This Cruel War Was Over. The entire book is required reading. This is a longer reading assignment than the Brown book, but here are some tips to help you read.

Based on your reading of the Manning book, your post should respond to ONE of the following two questions.

Option #1: In class on Thursday, Alex raised the question of why non-slaveholders in the South would fight for a Confederate government that was, according to its own Constitution, dedicated to upholding slavery. A related question is why Northern soldiers would ever fight in a war to emancipate slaves if they were not always fully committed to racial equality or abolition. Does Manning’s book offer any evidence or arguments to answer these two questions?

Option #2: The primary aim of Manning’s book is to understand what motivated soldiers in the ranks during the Civil War. Did soldiers’ thinking about the war change over time? To answer this question, focus on one of the two armies–Union or Confederate–and choose two moments in the War, at least a year apart. How were the motivations of soldiers at one of the moments you’ve chosen different from or similar to their motivations at the other moment?

While you’re reading Manning’s book and thinking about these questions, you may also want to pay attention to the basic chronology of the war–major turning points, battles, and events. In class we will not be studying all of the battles of the War in detail, so this book is your primary opportunity to get a basic overview of the war’s history from beginning to end. Taking some notes about the key military junctures and figures will be useful to you later in the class.

Unlike with your previous blog posts, do not post your response as a comment on this post. I’m going to be assigning you to your small groups over the weekend, and each small group will get its own group blog. Your blog post this week will be posted on that new small group blog. Instructions about how to do this will be given in class on Tuesday. [P.S. Instructions are now available here.] In the meantime, you may want to begin writing your response in a text file on your own computer so that you can copy and paste it into the blog post after Tuesday.

Blog Post #3 will be due by 9 a.m. next Thursday, January 27.

Blog Post #2

Friday, January 14th, 2011

Your second blog post assignment is based on the assigned reading for this week. You should read pp. 1-55 of Thomas Brown’s The Public Art of Civil War Commemoration and use specific evidence and examples from that reading when writing your comment. This book is a required text and is available in the Rice University bookstore and on 2-hour reserve at Fondren Library.

Your comment should do two things:

Task #1: Select one feature of the Dick Dowling statue in Hermann Park, which we visited yesterday, and compare it with the monuments whose designs and inscriptions are discussed by Brown on pp. 22-41. Then briefly answer: What conclusions would you draw about the Dowling statue based on its similarity to or difference from other monuments discussed by Brown? (If you would like to look refresh your memory of the statue, an anonymous local artist has posted some photographs of it on Flickr.)

Task #2: Based on your reading of Brown, come up with a potential question for research about the Dowling statue we saw. After reading Brown’s survey of post-Civil War commemorations of veterans, what would you most like to know about this statue in particular and its history? What do you think answering this question would tell us about the memory of the Civil War?

Post your responses to both tasks in the comment section below. You may wish to consult the blog post rubric (PDF) that Mercy discussed in class on Thursday to remind yourself about the important objectives for these posts. Your comment is due by 9 a.m. next Thursday, January 20.